Protein Bars & Candy
DrinkDigits Team
December 12, 2025
Last reviewed April 20, 2026

Barebells Soft Bar - Salted Peanut Caramel: Flavor & Nutrition Review

Barebells Soft Bar Salted Peanut Caramel Honest Review
8.1

⚡Quick Answer

The Barebells Soft Bar Salted Peanut Caramel is the closest thing to a high-protein Snickers on US shelves. Soft, chewy, and candy-bar-like with 15g protein and only 2g sugar per bar.

  • 15g whey protein, 193 calories, 2g sugar per 55g bar
  • Sweetened with maltitol and steviol glycosides (no added sugar)
  • Gluten-free, nougat-style chewy texture
  • 9g sugar alcohols, may cause digestive issues for sensitive eaters

We have been testing some of the most popular Protein Bars and Barebells is one of those brands people constantly recommend when you want a candy-bar-style protein bar. The Barebells Soft Bar - Salted Peanut Caramel stood out because it promises gooey caramel, roasted peanuts, soft nougat and a chocolate coating, so of course, we had to review it.

We evaluated it for flavor, sweetness, texture, nutrition, and how well it works as a protein snack or dessert replacement.

Product Snapshot

The Barebells Soft Bar Salted Peanut Caramel feels more like a soft, gooey candy bar than a typical protein bar. It is sweet, rich, and extremely satisfying - great for people who want a dessert-style protein snack, but definitely more of a treat than a clean ingredient option.

8.1

Best For

People who want candy-bar texture, gym-goers craving something sweet post-workout, peanut + caramel lovers and anyone wanting a satisfying protein treat.

Price:$29.99 (Box of 12 bars)
Serving Size:1 bar (55g)
Protein:16g
Sugar:2g
Sugar Alcohols:9g
Calories:210
What we noticed:Candy-bar-style protein bar, soft nougat with gooey caramel, real roasted peanut pieces, no protein aftertaste, higher sugar alcohols (9g) which may bother those with sensitive stomachs, slightly less protein than regular Barebells bars (16g vs. 20g).

Who They Are?

Barebells offers a variety of protein bars that are as tasty as they are nutritious. They focus on creating snacks that satisfy cravings while supporting a healthier lifestyle.

Nutrition Breakdown

Per 1 Barebells Soft Bar Salted Peanut Caramel (55g):

NutritionAmount
Calories210
Protein16g
Total Fat11g
Saturated Fat4.5g
Trans Fat0g
Cholesterol10mg
Sodium220mg
Total Carbohydrates21g
Dietary Fiber5g
Total Sugars2g
Includes Added Sugars0g
Sugar Alcohols9g
Calcium140mg
Iron0.8mg
Potassium150mg

← Swipe to see more →

CONTAINS: MILK, PEANUTS, SOYBEANS, WHEAT

MAY CONTAIN: TREE NUTS and SESAME

This is a candy-bar-style protein bar with gooey caramel, soft nougat, and real roasted peanuts. It has 16g protein and low sugar (2g), but contains 9g of sugar alcohols, which may bother those with sensitive stomachs.

Barebells Salted Peanut Caramel Review

Flavor A rich peanut flavor with a thick layer of caramel and smooth chocolate coating. Very close to a Snickers with slightly deeper roasted peanut notes. Dessert-like and extremely satisfying.

Texture Soft nougat, gooey caramel and peanut crunch. Chewy but not dense. Easily one of the most candy-bar-realistic textures available.

Sweetness Level Moderate sweetness despite only 2g sugar, the sugar alcohols provide sweetness without a chemical aftertaste. If you're sensitive to sugar alcohols then this is not for you.

Best Time to Eat Afternoon craving Dessert replacement Post-workout sweet fix When you want a candy bar without eating an actual candy bar

Flavor Accuracy, Texture, Nutrition, Taste & Value

Flavor Accuracy: Peanut + caramel exactly as expected

Texture: Soft, gooey, candy-bar-like

Nutrition: 16g protein, low sugar, high sugar alcohols

Taste: Dessert-like, rich, extremely satisfying

Value: Great for flavor lovers; not ideal for low-calorie eaters

Why We Love It?

  • Soft, gooey salted caramel and nougat
  • Tastes extremely close to a real candy bar
  • No chalky protein bar aftertaste
  • Peanut lovers will be obsessed

Other Barebells Soft Bar Flavors

  • Caramel Choco
  • Marshmallow Peanut Road
  • Minty Chocolate
  • Banana Caramel

How to Use This Bar?

  • Post-Workout: Great for a sweet protein fix after training.
  • Snack: Perfect for afternoon cravings or dessert replacement.

Buy If:

  • You want a candy-bar-style protein bar
  • You enjoy gooey caramel
  • You prefer dessert-style protein snacks
  • You want something sweet but still protein-focused

Skip If:

  • You avoid sugar alcohols
  • You want a low-calorie bar
  • You're sensitive to sugar alcohols (9g may cause digestive issues)
  • You prefer bars with higher protein (this has 16g vs. 20g in regular Barebells bars)

Related Reads

Sources & References

  1. Barebells Salted Peanut Caramel Soft Bar Product Page
  2. USDA FoodData Central, Protein Bar Nutrition Data
  3. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, Maltitol and glycemic response research
  4. FDA, Sugar alcohols labeling guidance for sugar-reduced foods

What We Think About Barebells Soft Bar - Salted Peanut Caramel?

This bar is one of the closest things to a high-protein Snickers we've ever tasted. It's soft, gooey, rich and extremely satisfying. If you're looking for a dessert-style protein bar or want something sweet post-workout, this one won't disappoint. If you're already a fan of Barebells, there's almost no chance you won't enjoy these too. If you are sensitive to sugar alcohols or want a low-calorie option, this may not be the best choice.

The Good

  • +Soft, gooey salted caramel and nougat
  • +Tastes extremely close to a real candy bar
  • +No chalky protein bar aftertaste
  • +Peanut lovers will be obsessed
  • +Real roasted peanut pieces
  • +One of the best candy-bar textures on the market

The Bad

  • -Higher sugar alcohols (9g) - may bother those with sensitive stomachs
  • -Slightly less protein than regular Barebells bars (16g vs. 20g)

Detailed Ratings

8.0
Flavor Accuracy
8.0
Nutrition
8.0
Taste
8.5
Texture
8.0
Value
8.1

Now this is good.

Strong flavor, clean ingredients, impressive macros the full package. You'll look forward to eating this. The group-chat-worthy tier.

Want to try the same one we reviewed?

Check it out

Frequently Asked Questions

It is firmly on the chewy, soft side, closer to a candy bar nougat than a crunchy protein bar. That is the whole selling point of Barebells: the texture mimics a Snickers or Twix instead of feeling like a pressed protein brick.

Best Alternatives

FITCRUNCH Wafer Protein Bar Raspberry Tart

FITCRUNCH Wafer Protein Bar Raspberry Tart

8.0
16g protein
Aloha Protein Bars

Aloha Protein Bars

8.0
14g protein
Zing Bar Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip

Zing Bar Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip

6.8
10g protein